iLabs Shunya

Maths, minus the myths

50 maths myths & paradoxes

0.999… is less than 1. You can divide by zero. Two negatives 'just make a positive'. You've heard them all, and they are (mostly) wrong. Here are the 50 most common maths myths and paradoxes, each with the truth, the reasoning behind it, and something to try with a pencil.

Start busting
50 myths17 from everyday lifeClass 9–12 & JEETest them in the labs
Showing 50 of 50
#01 Numbers & arithmetic Everyday maths

0.999… is almost 1, but not quite 1

Nine, nine, nine, nine… still not 1? Bring a ruler. You will run out of paper first.

The myth

0.999… (nines forever) is just a tiny bit less than 1.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

0.999… is exactly equal to 1. They are two ways of writing the same number.

The maths: Let x = 0.999… Then 10x = 9.999…, so 10x − x = 9, which gives 9x = 9 and x = 1. Or: 1/3 = 0.333…, and three thirds make 1 = 0.999…. There is no number between 0.999… and 1, so they cannot be different.

Try it yourself: Ask a friend to name a number that lies between 0.999… and 1. They can't: the gap is smaller than any gap you can write down.

Test it: 0.999… → fraction in the Maths Explainers →

#02 Numbers & arithmetic

Divide by zero and you get infinity

Your calculator says 'Error'. It is not being lazy. It is being honest.

The myth

5 ÷ 0 = ∞ (or maybe 0).

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

Division by zero is undefined. There is no number that works.

The maths: a ÷ b = c means c × b = a. For 5 ÷ 0 we would need a number c with c × 0 = 5, but anything times 0 is 0. And the values of 1/x as x → 0 head to +∞ from the right and −∞ from the left, so there is no single answer even as a limit.

Try it yourself: Type 1 ÷ 0.1, 1 ÷ 0.01, 1 ÷ 0.001 … then 1 ÷ −0.1, 1 ÷ −0.01 … and watch the answers run off in opposite directions.

Test it: the limit of 1 ÷ x at 0 in the Calculus lab →

#03 Numbers & arithmetic

Zero is neither even nor odd, it's nothing

Zero is the most even number there is. It just never gets invited to parties.

The myth

Zero is not even and not odd, because it is 'nothing'.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

Zero is an even number, just like 2, 4 and 6.

The maths: An even number is a whole number divisible by 2, and 0 ÷ 2 = 0 exactly. It is 2 × 0. Even and odd numbers alternate on the number line (… −1, 0, 1, 2 …), and the neighbours of 0 are odd, so 0 must be even.

Try it yourself: Check the rule 'even + even = even' with 0: 4 + 0 = 4 still works. Try the same test if you call zero odd: odd + odd should be even, but 1 + 0 = 1 would break it.

#04 Numbers & arithmetic Everyday maths

Multiplying always makes a number bigger

Half of a half is a quarter. That is multiplication making things smaller, and pizza knows it.

The myth

If you multiply a number by another number, the answer is bigger.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

Only when you multiply by a number greater than 1. Multiplying by a fraction between 0 and 1 makes it smaller, and multiplying by a negative flips its sign.

The maths: Multiplying by 0.5 means 'take half', so 8 × 0.5 = 4. Multiplying by −2 doubles the size and reverses the direction: 8 × (−2) = −16. Multiplication is scaling, and scaling can shrink.

Try it yourself: Ask for 0.25 of a 200 rupee bill: 0.25 × 200 = 50. The answer is smaller than 200 even though you multiplied.

#05 Numbers & arithmetic

'Minus times minus is plus' is just a rule someone made up

It is not a rule. It is a consequence. Nobody gets to vote on it.

The myth

(−2) × (−3) = −6 would be just as fair. Plus is an arbitrary choice.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

(−2) × (−3) = +6 is forced: any other answer breaks the ordinary rules of arithmetic.

The maths: Start from (−3) + 3 = 0. Multiply by −2: (−2)(−3) + (−2)(3) = 0. Since (−2)(3) = −6, the number (−2)(−3) must be +6 for the sum to be 0. The distributive law needs it. On the number line, multiplying by −1 is a half-turn, and two half-turns make a full turn back to the start.

Try it yourself: Play 'the enemy of my enemy': two flips of direction bring you back facing the way you started.

#06 Numbers & arithmetic Everyday maths

−5 is bigger than −2 because 5 is bigger than 2

Anyone who has owed money knows that owing 5 is worse than owing 2.

The myth

−5 > −2, because the numbers with bigger digits are bigger.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

−2 is greater than −5. On the number line, greater means further right.

The maths: −5 lies to the left of −2, so −5 < −2. A temperature of −5 °C is colder than −2 °C, and a debt of 5 rupees is worse than a debt of 2. Adding a positive number moves you right, so −5 + 3 = −2 shows −2 is bigger.

Try it yourself: Draw a number line from −6 to 6 and mark −5 and −2. The one on the right is the greater number.

#07 Numbers & arithmetic

1 is a prime number

1 has only itself as a factor. That sounds like a prime, but it is a unit, and units are a different club.

The myth

A prime is a number divisible only by 1 and itself, so 1 is prime.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

1 is not prime. A prime has exactly two different positive factors, and 1 has just one.

The maths: If 1 were prime, prime factorisation would no longer be unique: 6 = 2 × 3 = 1 × 2 × 3 = 1 × 1 × 2 × 3 … The fundamental theorem of arithmetic says every whole number greater than 1 factors into primes in exactly one way, so 1 is excluded.

Try it yourself: List the factors of 7 (1 and 7) and of 1 (just 1). A prime has exactly two.

#08 Numbers & arithmetic

All prime numbers are odd

2 is the only even prime, which makes it the oddest prime of all.

The myth

Every prime number is odd.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

2 is prime and even. It is the only even prime.

The maths: 2 has exactly two factors, 1 and 2, so it is prime. Every other even number is divisible by 2 and also greater than 2, so it has a factor other than 1 and itself, which means it is not prime.

Try it yourself: Try to find another even prime. Any even number above 2 has 2 as a factor and is itself bigger than 2, so it fails.

#09 Numbers & arithmetic Everyday maths

π is exactly 22 ÷ 7

22/7 is π's stunt double. Close enough for the camera, not for the crash scene.

The myth

π is exactly equal to the fraction 22/7.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

22/7 ≈ 3.142857… is only an approximation. π = 3.14159265… is irrational: its decimals never end and never repeat.

The maths: 22/7 is a fraction, so its decimal repeats (142857 forever). π is not a fraction of two whole numbers, so its decimal never repeats. The gap is small but real: 22/7 − π ≈ 0.00126. A better fraction is 355/113 ≈ 3.14159292.

Try it yourself: Divide 22 by 7 and 355 by 113 on a calculator, then compare with the π button.

Test it: 22 ÷ 7 in the Maths Explainers →

#10 Numbers & arithmetic Everyday maths

To add fractions, add the tops and add the bottoms

Half a pizza plus a third of a pizza is not two-fifths of a pizza. It is five-sixths, and it's way tastier.

The myth

To add fractions you add the tops and add the bottoms: 1/2 + 1/3 = 2/5.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

1/2 + 1/3 = 5/6. You need a common denominator first.

The maths: Halves and thirds are pieces of different size, so you cannot add them until you cut both into sixths: 3/6 + 2/6 = 5/6. The 'add tops and bottoms' answer 2/5 is smaller than 1/2, which is impossible since you added something positive to 1/2.

Try it yourself: A quick sanity check: the sum must be bigger than each part. 2/5 = 0.4 is smaller than 1/2, so the shortcut fails.

#11 Numbers & arithmetic Everyday maths

Up 50% then down 50% puts you back where you started

Your share price goes up half, then down half. Your wallet goes down a quarter. Nobody warned you.

The myth

A 50% increase followed by a 50% decrease returns the original amount.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

You end up 25% lower. 100 → 150 → 75.

The maths: Percentages are always of the current amount. 50% of 100 is 50, giving 150, but 50% of 150 is 75, giving 75. In multiplication terms, 1.5 × 0.5 = 0.75, not 1. To undo a 50% rise you need a fall of one third.

Try it yourself: Try it with ₹200: add 50% (₹300), then take off 50% (₹150). Compare with the ₹200 you began with.

#12 Algebra & equations Everyday maths

(a + b)² = a² + b²

The middle term 2ab is the bit everyone forgets, and the bit the exam always tests.

The myth

Squaring a sum just squares each part: (a + b)² = a² + b².

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

(a + b)² = a² + 2ab + b². The cross term 2ab is missing from the myth.

The maths: (a + b)² means (a + b)(a + b). Multiply out: a·a + a·b + b·a + b·b = a² + 2ab + b². As a picture, a square of side a + b is made of an a-square, a b-square and two a-by-b rectangles. Check with a = 3, b = 4: (3 + 4)² = 49, but 9 + 16 = 25.

Try it yourself: Cut a square of side 7 into a 3 × 3 square, a 4 × 4 square and two 3 × 4 rectangles. The four pieces fill it exactly.

Test it: draw y = (x + 3)² and y = x² + 9 in the Function Explorer →

#13 Algebra & equations

√(a² + b²) = a + b

If that were true, the shortcut across a field would be no shorter than walking round the edge.

The myth

The square root of a sum of squares is the sum: √(3² + 4²) = 3 + 4 = 7.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

√(3² + 4²) = √25 = 5, not 7. In general √(a² + b²) < a + b for positive a and b.

The maths: Square roots do not split over addition. That is exactly why the diagonal of a right triangle (Pythagoras) is shorter than the two sides added together: it is the straight line, and the triangle inequality says a straight line is the shortest route.

Try it yourself: Walk along two sides of a rectangular room, then along its diagonal, and count your steps.

Test it: Pythagoras in the Geometry lab →

#14 Algebra & equations

x² = 4 means x = 2

Half the answer is still a wrong answer. Ask a quadratic how many roots it has.

The myth

If x² = 4 then x = 2.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

x = 2 or x = −2. The equation has two solutions.

The maths: Both 2² and (−2)² equal 4. Solving x² − 4 = 0 gives (x − 2)(x + 2) = 0, so x = 2 or x = −2. The symbol √4 means only the positive value 2, but the equation x² = 4 asks for every x that works.

Try it yourself: Sketch y = x² and the line y = 4: the line cuts the curve at two points, one on each side.

Test it: two zeros of a quadratic in the Function Explorer →

#15 Algebra & equations

(x − 1)(x − 2) = 6 means x − 1 = 6 or x − 2 = 6

The zero-product rule only works with 0. Six is not a zero, however hard you stare at it.

The myth

If a product equals 6, then one of the factors equals 6.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

That only works when the product is 0. If (x − 1)(x − 2) = 6, first move everything to one side: x² − 3x − 4 = 0.

The maths: If ab = 0 then a = 0 or b = 0, because you cannot make 0 by multiplying two non-zero numbers. But many pairs multiply to 6: 2 × 3, 1 × 6, (−2) × (−3) … so nothing forces a factor to be 6. Solve x² − 3x − 4 = (x − 4)(x + 1) = 0 to get x = 4 or x = −1.

Try it yourself: Test the 'wrong' answer x = 7: (7 − 1)(7 − 2) = 30, not 6.

#16 Algebra & equations

Squaring both sides of an equation is always safe

Squaring is a one-way street: it lets in unwelcome guests who pretend to be answers.

The myth

You can square both sides of an equation and keep all the same solutions.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

Squaring can add fake solutions (extraneous roots), so you must check every answer in the original equation.

The maths: x = −2 is not a solution of x = 2, but squaring gives x² = 4, which has −2 as a solution. Squaring merges a and −a. Example: √(x + 2) = x. Squaring gives x + 2 = x², so x = 2 or x = −1, but x = −1 gives √1 = 1 ≠ −1, so only x = 2 works.

Try it yourself: After you solve any equation that involved a square or a square root, plug the answers back in.

#17 Algebra & equations

Multiply both sides of an inequality by anything and the sign stays

Multiply by −1 and the whole world turns round. So does the inequality sign.

The myth

If 2 < 3 then −2 × 2 < −2 × 3.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

Multiplying or dividing by a negative number reverses the inequality: 2 < 3 becomes −4 > −6.

The maths: On the number line, multiplying by a negative number reflects it through 0, which swaps left and right. Since −4 lies to the right of −6, −4 > −6. Multiplying by a positive number does not reflect anything, so the sign stays.

Try it yourself: Start with 1 < 2. Multiply by −1: you get −1 and −2. Which is bigger now?

#18 Algebra & equations

The proof that 1 = 2 (so maths is broken)

It is a magic trick, and the disappearing act is a division by zero.

The myth

Let a = b. Then a² = ab, so a² − b² = ab − b², so (a + b)(a − b) = b(a − b). Cancel to get a + b = b, so 2b = b, so 2 = 1.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

The proof is invalid. It divides both sides by (a − b), and since a = b that is dividing by zero.

The maths: Every step until the cancellation is correct, but (a + b)(a − b) = b(a − b) is really 0 = 0, which is true whatever the numbers are. Cancelling (a − b) divides by 0, and that step is not allowed. Bogus proofs almost always hide a division by zero or a wrongly used square root.

Try it yourself: Substitute a = b = 1 into each line and see where 'true' quietly becomes 'both sides are 0'.

#19 Geometry & measurement Everyday maths

A square is not a rectangle

Every square is a rectangle. Not every rectangle is a square, just like not every Tamil speaker is from Chennai.

The myth

A square and a rectangle are different shapes.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

A square is a special rectangle: a rectangle whose sides are all equal.

The maths: A rectangle is a quadrilateral with four right angles. A square has four right angles too, so it qualifies. In the same way a square is also a rhombus (four equal sides) and a parallelogram. The shapes are nested, like boxes inside boxes.

Try it yourself: Draw a rectangle and slowly make its two different sides equal. At the moment they match, it has become a square, without ever leaving the family.

Test it: bend quadrilaterals in the Geometry lab →

#20 Geometry & measurement Half true

The angles of a triangle always add up to 180°

True on your notebook page. On a globe, the triangle has other ideas.

The myth

In every triangle the angles add up to exactly 180°.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

True for triangles on a flat surface. On a curved surface such as a sphere, the angles add up to more than 180°.

The maths: Take the North Pole and two points on the equator 90° of longitude apart. The triangle has three right angles, so its angles add to 270°. The 180° rule follows from Euclid's parallel postulate, which holds on flat surfaces only.

Try it yourself: Draw a triangle on an orange with a marker: two lines from the 'pole' down to the 'equator', then along the equator. Measure the corners.

Test it: the angle sum of a triangle in the Geometry lab →

#21 Geometry & measurement

Bigger circles have a bigger π

π is the same for a coin and for the equator. That is what makes it a constant.

The myth

A large circle's circumference divided by its diameter is different from a small circle's.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

For every circle, circumference ÷ diameter is the same number, π ≈ 3.14159.

The maths: All circles are scaled copies of each other (similar figures). If you double the diameter, the circumference also doubles, so their ratio never changes. That single fixed ratio is what we call π.

Try it yourself: Wrap a string around a bangle, a plate and a dustbin lid. Measure each circumference and diameter, and divide. You will get about 3.14 each time.

Test it: circles in the Circles & Conics lab →

#22 Geometry & measurement Everyday maths

Double the sides and the area doubles

Order a 14 inch pizza instead of 7 inch and you get four times the pizza, not twice. The price will not be four times, so it's a bargain.

The myth

If you double every length of a shape, its area doubles.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

The area becomes 4 times bigger. The volume of a solid becomes 8 times bigger.

The maths: Area is length × length, so the scale factor is squared: 2² = 4. Volume is length × length × length, so it is cubed: 2³ = 8. This is also why big animals need thick legs: weight goes up with the cube, but the bone's cross-section only with the square.

Try it yourself: Build a 2 × 2 × 2 block from 1 × 1 × 1 cubes: it takes 8 cubes and shows 4 times the surface on each face.

Test it: resize solids in the Mensuration lab →

#23 Geometry & measurement Everyday maths

On a flat map, a straight line is the shortest route

That is why long flights, such as Delhi to San Francisco, swing far north near the Arctic. The pilot is not lost.

The myth

The shortest path between two places is a straight line on the map.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

On the Earth the shortest path is a great-circle arc, which usually looks curved on a flat map.

The maths: A flat map stretches the curved surface of the Earth, so straight lines on a map are not shortest routes on the globe. A great circle is what you get by cutting the sphere through its centre, and the shortest path between two points lies along one.

Try it yourself: Stretch a string between two cities on a globe. The taut string is the shortest path, and it bends when you copy it onto a flat map.

#24 Geometry & measurement Half true

Parallel lines never meet

On a flat page, never. On a globe, all the lines of longitude meet at the poles.

The myth

Two parallel lines never meet, anywhere, ever.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

In flat (Euclidean) geometry this is the definition of parallel. But on curved surfaces, 'straight' lines can start parallel and still meet.

The maths: Two lines of longitude both cross the equator at a right angle, so they start out parallel, yet they meet at the North Pole. Euclid's parallel postulate, which says there is exactly one parallel through a point, holds on a plane but not on a sphere.

Try it yourself: On a globe, put two fingers on the equator and follow two meridians north.

#25 Geometry & measurement Everyday maths

A cone holds half as much as a cylinder of the same size

The ice-cream cone is a bargain hunter's nightmare. It holds exactly one third of the cup next to it.

The myth

A cone with the same base and height as a cylinder has half its volume.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

A cone has exactly one third of the volume of the cylinder: V = ⅓πr²h.

The maths: The cone's cross-sections shrink from the full base size to a point, and adding them all up gives one third of the cylinder's volume. You can check it by pouring: three cones of water fill the cylinder exactly.

Try it yourself: Make a cone and a cylinder of the same base and height from card, fill the cone with rice and pour it into the cylinder three times.

Test it: pour cones into a cylinder in the Mensuration lab →

#26 Geometry & measurement

Any three lengths can make a triangle

Try building a triangle from sticks of 1, 2 and 3. You will get a very sad straight line.

The myth

If I have three sticks of any lengths, I can join them into a triangle.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

The two shorter sides must add up to more than the longest side (the triangle inequality). Sticks of 1, 2 and 3 only make a flat line.

The maths: The shortest way between two corners is a straight line, so one side can never be longer than the other two put together. If 1 + 2 = 3, the two short sticks lie flat along the long one. With 2, 3 and 4 they can swing apart to make a real triangle.

Try it yourself: Cut straws to 2, 3 and 6 cm and try to join them. Then try 2, 3 and 4.

Test it: drag a triangle corner onto a line in the Mensuration lab and watch the area reach 0 →

#27 Geometry & measurement Everyday maths

Shapes with the same perimeter have the same area

A farmer with 20 metres of fence wants the biggest field. Square wins, a long thin rectangle loses.

The myth

If two shapes have the same perimeter, they enclose the same area.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

Perimeter does not fix the area. A rectangle with perimeter 20 can have area 9 (1 × 9) or 25 (5 × 5).

The maths: For a fixed perimeter, the more 'round' the shape, the more area it holds. Among rectangles the square is best, and among all shapes the circle is best. That is why bubbles are round.

Try it yourself: Make a loop of 20 cm of string. Shape it into a thin rectangle, a square and a circle, then compare how much space each one covers.

Test it: area and perimeter in the Mensuration lab →

#28 Geometry & measurement

Pythagoras' theorem works for every triangle

a² + b² = c² is a private club for right triangles.

The myth

In any triangle, a² + b² = c².

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

It holds only for right-angled triangles, where c is the side opposite the right angle. For other triangles, the law of cosines gives c² = a² + b² − 2ab cos C.

The maths: When the angle C is 90°, cos C = 0 and the extra term disappears, leaving Pythagoras. For an acute angle the term is positive so c² < a² + b², and for an obtuse angle c² > a² + b². The check a² + b² versus c² tells you the kind of triangle.

Try it yourself: Test a triangle with sides 4, 5 and 6: 16 + 25 = 41, which is bigger than 36, so it has no right angle (and it is acute).

Test it: right triangles in the Trigonometry lab →

#29 Functions & calculus

Every graph is the graph of a function

A circle is a perfectly good shape and a terrible function.

The myth

Any curve you can draw on a graph paper represents a function.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

A function gives exactly one output for each input, so no vertical line can cut its graph more than once (the vertical line test).

The maths: The circle x² + y² = 25 has, for x = 3, two points: y = 4 and y = −4. One input, two outputs, so it is not a function. Split it into two halves, y = √(25 − x²) and y = −√(25 − x²), and each half is a function.

Try it yourself: Hold a pencil vertically and sweep it across a graph. If it ever touches the graph twice at once, it is not a function.

Test it: plot functions in the Function Explorer →

#30 Functions & calculus

sin(A + B) = sin A + sin B

sin 30° + sin 60° = 1.37, but sin 90° = 1. The sine has no interest in distributing.

The myth

Sine of a sum is the sum of the sines.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

sin(A + B) = sin A cos B + cos A sin B.

The maths: A function does not usually 'split' over addition. Test it: sin 30° = 0.5 and sin 60° ≈ 0.866, whose sum is 1.366, but sin 90° = 1. The true formula has cross terms, just as (a + b)² does. It can be shown with a unit-circle picture or by rotating a vector.

Try it yourself: Use a calculator with A = 30° and B = 60°, and compute both sides.

Test it: the unit circle in the Trigonometry lab →

#31 Functions & calculus

The derivative of a product is the product of the derivatives

It would make calculus much easier. Which is exactly why it isn't true.

The myth

To differentiate a product, multiply the two derivatives: (f × g)′ = f′ × g′.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

(f g)′ = f′ g + f g′. This is the product rule.

The maths: Take f = g = x. Then f g = x², whose derivative is 2x. The myth would give f′ × g′ = 1 × 1 = 1. The product rule gives 1·x + x·1 = 2x, which is correct. Think of a rectangle with sides f and g: as both sides change, the area gains a strip along each side.

Try it yourself: Differentiate x·x by the myth and by the product rule, then compare with the known derivative of x².

Test it: derivatives in the Calculus lab →

#32 Functions & calculus

A limit is a value the function never reaches

The limit is where the function is heading, not always where it isn't.

The myth

If a limit is L, the function gets close to L but never actually equals L.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

A function may reach its limit, never reach it, or reach it many times. The limit describes where values are heading, not what happens on the way.

The maths: For f(x) = 5 (a constant), every value equals its limit 5. For f(x) = sin(x) ÷ x, the value at x = 0 is missing, but the limit is 1. For f(x) = (sin x) ÷ x again, as x → ∞ the values cross the limit 0 infinitely often. So 'never reaches' is not part of the definition.

Try it yourself: Draw the graph of y = sin(x) ÷ x for large x and see it wiggle across y = 0 while heading for it.

Test it: limits in the Calculus lab →

#33 Functions & calculus

If f′(x) = 0 then f has a maximum or a minimum there

The curve stops climbing for a second, then carries on climbing. Not every pause is a summit.

The myth

A point where the derivative is zero must be a peak or a valley.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

A zero derivative only means the tangent is horizontal. It can also be an inflection point, as for f(x) = x³ at x = 0.

The maths: For f(x) = x³, f′(x) = 3x² is 0 at x = 0, yet the curve keeps rising on both sides. To decide, check whether f′ changes sign (from + to − is a maximum, from − to + is a minimum) or use the second derivative test.

Try it yourself: Plot y = x³ and y = x². Both have zero slope at 0. Only one has a valley there.

Test it: maxima and minima in the Calculus lab →

#34 Functions & calculus

A continuous function must be smooth

You can draw |x| without lifting your pencil, but you will get a sharp corner in your hand.

The myth

If you can draw a graph without lifting your pen, it has a slope everywhere.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

Continuous does not mean differentiable. The graph of f(x) = |x| is unbroken but has a sharp corner at 0, where the slope is undefined.

The maths: At x = 0 the slope approaching from the left is −1 and from the right is +1. They disagree, so there is no single tangent. Differentiable implies continuous, but not the other way round.

Try it yourself: Try to draw one tangent line at the point of V on the graph of y = |x|. Which one would you choose?

Test it: corners and continuity in the Calculus lab →

#35 Functions & calculus

An integral is always an area, and areas are positive

The integral of sin x from 0 to 2π is 0. The area there is certainly not zero.

The myth

A definite integral gives the (positive) area between the curve and the axis.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

An integral gives the signed area: parts below the x-axis count as negative.

The maths: From 0 to π, sin x is above the axis with area 2; from π to 2π it is below with area −2. They cancel to give 0. If you want the total (unsigned) area, split the interval where the curve crosses the axis and add the absolute values: 2 + 2 = 4.

Try it yourself: Cut out the two humps of one sine wave from paper. They are the same size, so they weigh the same.

Test it: signed and total area in the Calculus lab →

#36 Functions & calculus

x¹⁰⁰ eventually grows faster than 2ˣ

The polynomial gets a head start, and the exponential lets it, and then it overtakes it forever.

The myth

A big power of x always beats an exponential like 2ˣ.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

No matter how large the power, an exponential aⁿ (with a > 1) eventually overtakes it and stays ahead.

The maths: For a while x¹⁰⁰ is far bigger than 2ˣ. But 2ˣ doubles every step, while x¹⁰⁰ only grows by the factor (1 + 1/x)¹⁰⁰, which tends to 1. Beyond a certain x (roughly 1000), 2ˣ wins for good. That is the difference between polynomial and exponential growth.

Try it yourself: Compare x² and 2ˣ: at x = 3 you get 9 and 8, at x = 4 you get 16 and 16, at x = 5 you get 25 and 32.

Test it: compare growth in the Function Explorer →

#37 Probability & statistics Everyday maths

After five heads in a row, tails is due

The coin has no memory. It has never heard of you.

The myth

The coin has to even things out, so the next flip is more likely to be tails.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

The next flip is still 50–50. Each flip is independent of the ones before.

The maths: The gambler's fallacy mistakes the law of large numbers for a force that corrects the past. Over thousands of flips the proportion of heads gets close to 1/2, but not because the coin compensates: the early streak just gets diluted by all the later flips.

Try it yourself: Flip a coin 20 times and write down the longest run. Runs of 4 or 5 are normal.

Test it: flip coins by the thousand in the Probability lab →

#38 Probability & statistics

Flip a fair coin 10 times and you'll get exactly 5 heads

Exactly 5 heads happens about a quarter of the time. The coin is not being unfair, just being random.

The myth

A fair coin means half heads and half tails in any set of flips.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

The probability of exactly 5 heads in 10 flips is only about 24.6%.

The maths: There are 2¹⁰ = 1024 equally likely outcomes, and C(10, 5) = 252 of them have exactly 5 heads, so P = 252 ÷ 1024 ≈ 0.246. Results like 4 or 6 heads are just as ordinary. The proportion gets closer to one half as you flip more, but the exact count does not.

Try it yourself: Flip a coin 10 times, ten times over. Count how many of the ten rounds gave exactly 5 heads.

Test it: the binomial curve in the Probability lab →

#39 Probability & statistics Everyday maths

The average tells you what is typical

When a billionaire walks into a bar, the average person in the bar becomes a millionaire.

The myth

The mean of a set of numbers shows the typical value.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

The mean is pulled by extreme values. The median, the middle value, is often a better 'typical' number.

The maths: Five salaries: ₹20k, ₹22k, ₹25k, ₹28k and ₹500k. The mean is ₹119k, which nobody earns. The median is ₹25k, which describes most of the group. Whenever the data has outliers or is skewed (incomes, house prices), quote the median.

Try it yourself: Ask the class for their pocket money, then add the richest person's amount as 100 times bigger. See what happens to the mean and to the median.

Test it: drag data points in the Probability lab →

#40 Probability & statistics Everyday maths

You need 183 people for a shared birthday to be likely

In a class of 23 there is a better than even chance that two people share a birthday. The birthday cake budget is at risk.

The myth

You need about half of 365 (that is 183) people before a shared birthday is 50% likely.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

With just 23 people the chance of at least two sharing a birthday is about 50.7%.

The maths: Count pairs, not people: 23 people make 253 different pairs, and each pair has a 1/365 chance of matching. Precisely, P(no match) = (365/365)(364/365)…(343/365) ≈ 0.493, so P(match) ≈ 0.507. With 70 people it is over 99.9%.

Try it yourself: Check the birthdays of everyone in your class, or of the players in two football teams (22 players).

#41 Probability & statistics

A family has two children and at least one is a boy: the other is a boy with probability 1/2

It feels like a coin flip, but the sample space says otherwise.

The myth

If one child is a boy, the other is equally likely to be a boy or a girl, so it's 1/2.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

If all you know is 'at least one is a boy', the chance that both are boys is 1/3.

The maths: The equally likely families are BB, BG, GB and GG. 'At least one boy' rules out GG and leaves BB, BG, GB, three cases, only one of which is BB. If you instead know 'the older child is a boy', the cases are BB and BG, so the chance is 1/2. The wording matters.

Try it yourself: Write the four possible two-child families and cross out the ones the clue forbids.

#42 Probability & statistics

Monty Hall: with two doors left it's 50–50, so switching is pointless

Even famous mathematicians got this one wrong in public. You are in good company.

The myth

After the host opens one losing door, the prize is equally likely behind each of the other two doors.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

Switching wins 2 times out of 3. Staying wins only 1 time out of 3.

The maths: Your first pick is right 1/3 of the time and wrong 2/3 of the time. If it was wrong (2/3), the host is forced to open the only other losing door, so the remaining door has the prize. Switching therefore wins whenever your first pick was wrong: 2/3.

Try it yourself: Play it with three cups and a coin under one of them. Play 30 rounds of 'always stay', then 30 rounds of 'always switch'.

Test it: simulate draws in the Probability lab →

#43 Probability & statistics

If two things go up together, one causes the other

Ice cream sales and drowning both rise in summer. Ban ice cream? No. It's hot weather.

The myth

When two quantities are strongly correlated, one must be causing the other.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

Correlation is not causation. A third factor, or pure coincidence, can make two things move together.

The maths: Ice-cream sales and drownings both rise in summer because of hot weather, which drives both. Correlation only measures how well two sets of data move together on a line. To show causation you need a controlled experiment or a good causal argument.

Try it yourself: Find your own funny example: number of umbrellas sold and number of colds could both rise in the rainy season.

#44 Probability & statistics Everyday maths

1-2-3-4-5-6 is less likely to win the lottery than a 'random' set

Every combination is equally unlikely, including the one you would never pick.

The myth

A pattern like 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 is much less likely than a random-looking set.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

Every particular set of six numbers has exactly the same chance of being drawn.

The maths: In a 6-out-of-49 lottery there are C(49, 6) = 13,983,816 equally likely sets, and 1-2-3-4-5-6 is one of them, just like your birthday numbers. The 'random-looking' sets are more numerous as a class, but each single set is no likelier. The tip: if you win, so will everyone who picked the popular pattern, so pick unusual numbers to avoid sharing the prize.

Try it yourself: Use dice or a random-number app to generate a set, then write the pattern next to it. Both are one line in the 13,983,816.

#45 Probability & statistics Everyday maths

A 99% accurate test says positive: you're 99% likely to have the disease

The test is right 99% of the time, and yet most positive results are false alarms. Welcome to base rates.

The myth

If a test is 99% accurate and it comes back positive, there's a 99% chance you are ill.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

It depends on how common the disease is. If 1 person in 1000 has it, a positive result means only about a 9% chance of being ill.

The maths: Take 100,000 people. 100 are ill and 99 of them test positive. Of the 99,900 healthy people, 1% (999) also test positive. So of 1098 positive tests, only 99 are real: 99 ÷ 1098 ≈ 9%. This is Bayes' theorem: rare conditions produce mostly false positives.

Try it yourself: Draw the 100,000 people as a tree with four branches (ill/healthy, positive/negative) and count.

#46 Infinity & paradoxes

Infinity is the biggest number

Infinity plus one is still infinity. Also infinity times infinity. This is the fun part.

The myth

∞ is a number, the largest one, and you can do ordinary arithmetic with it.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

Infinity is not a real number. It describes something that goes on without end, and the usual arithmetic rules do not apply to it.

The maths: If ∞ were a number, ∞ + 1 = ∞ would give 1 = 0 after subtracting ∞. Expressions like ∞ − ∞ or ∞ ÷ ∞ have no fixed value. In calculus, ∞ shows up as 'grows without bound', in the language of limits.

Try it yourself: Ask: what is the biggest whole number? Whatever you say, add 1. There is no biggest, which is the idea of infinity.

#47 Infinity & paradoxes

There are fewer even numbers than whole numbers

Hilbert's hotel is full, but a new guest can always be given a room. This is not a hotel review.

The myth

Half the whole numbers are even, so there are half as many even numbers as whole numbers.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

There are exactly as many even numbers as whole numbers. Both are the same kind of infinity.

The maths: Pair every whole number n with the even number 2n: 1 ↔ 2, 2 ↔ 4, 3 ↔ 6 … Every whole number gets exactly one partner, and every even number is used exactly once. Two collections with a perfect pairing have the same size. Galileo noticed the same thing with squares.

Try it yourself: Write the whole numbers in a row and their doubles in a row beneath them, and try to find one that is left over.

#48 Infinity & paradoxes

All infinities are the same size

Some infinities are bigger than others. Cantor proved it, and then got into trouble for it.

The myth

Infinite means infinite. There is only one size.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

The real numbers are a bigger infinity than the whole numbers. You cannot list all the real numbers, however cleverly you try.

The maths: Cantor's diagonal argument: suppose you could list all decimals between 0 and 1. Build a new decimal whose first digit differs from the first decimal in your list, whose second digit differs from the second, and so on. It is not the same as any number on the list, so the list was incomplete. The whole numbers, fractions and even-numbers can be listed, but the real numbers cannot.

Try it yourself: Write a list of any five decimals and use the diagonal trick to build a sixth that isn't in the list.

#49 Infinity & paradoxes

Achilles can never overtake the tortoise

Zeno said motion is impossible. He never had to catch a bus.

The myth

Each time Achilles reaches where the tortoise was, the tortoise has moved on, so he never catches up.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

Achilles does catch up. Infinitely many steps can add up to a finite time.

The maths: Let Achilles run at 10 m/s and the tortoise at 1 m/s, with a 90 m head start. The gaps are 90 m, 9 m, 0.9 m … and the times are 9 s, 0.9 s, 0.09 s … These form a geometric series with sum 9 ÷ (1 − 0.1) = 10 seconds. Adding infinitely many shrinking pieces can give a finite total.

Try it yourself: Add 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + … on a calculator. It creeps towards 1 and never goes past it.

Test it: a geometric series settling on its sum in the Maths Explainers →

#50 Infinity & paradoxes

If a pattern works for the first 40 cases, it's proven

n² + n + 41 makes primes for 40 numbers in a row. Then it makes 1681 = 41 × 41. Examples are not proofs.

The myth

Checking a formula for many examples proves it is true.

Myth or fact? Take a guess.
The truth

Examples can suggest a pattern, but only a proof shows it always holds. Some patterns fail after a long run of successes.

The maths: n² + n + 41 is prime for every n from 0 to 39. At n = 40 it equals 40² + 40 + 41 = 1681 = 41 × 41, which is not prime. A proof works for all n at once, using reasoning (like induction) instead of testing cases. A single counterexample, on the other hand, is enough to disprove a claim.

Try it yourself: Test n² + n + 41 for n = 0, 1, 2, 3 … until you reach 40. Then look at the result.

Heard a maths myth we missed, or think we got one wrong? Tell us. Mathematicians love being corrected (as long as it comes with a proof).

Tell us